Five Fabulously Full Days in Florence


I have the unenviable task of writing about our time in Florence, which included visits to 9 churches, 4 museums, 4 palaces and 2 gardens, knowing full well that almost everyone receiving this note has walked these stone slab streets, trudged through these museums, marveled at these art works, and taken enough photos to fill a bookshelf of albums. Undaunted, my fingers tense above the keys and I begin . . .


From a distance, Florence (Firenze to Italians) appears like the perfect tourist destination. With over 60 museums, most of which are packed into a walkable centro storico, and a concentration of more 14th and 15th century artwork than any city in the world, it has been a premiere stop on the Grand Tour since the early 17th century. Recent statistics suggest that as many as 80,000 tourists a day from every corner of the earth vie for spots in the long lines before such popular items as the Uffizi and Accademia. Which, as you have already guessed, means that you are literally rubbing shoulders with the world. But we were up to the challenge.



In planning our trip we came to the conclusion that by buying the Firenzecard, which gives you free access to most of the city’s attractions, we were sure to save money. Of course, the problem is that you have a tendency to think “how much money could I save?” Which leads inevitably to trying to cram as many entrances as possible into the 3 days allowed by the card. Which leads to exhaustion. Which is exactly what happened.


I will try to avoid exhausting the reader with every detail and instead provide a quick chronology and point out a few moments that were especially meaningful to us. So here is what our itinerary looked like:


Monday pm Tuesday Wednesday

Galileo Museum Pitti Palace Uffizi Gallery

Medici Riccardi Palace Boboli Gardens Brancacci Chapel

Palazzo Vecchio Basilica of San Lorenzo Bargello Museum

Basilica of Santa Maria Novella Basilica of Santa Croce

Bardini Gardens

    

Thursday             Friday

Museum of San Marco     Recovery

Palazzo Vecchio Tower climb Basilica di San Miniato al Monte

Davanzati Palace

Basilica di Santo Spirito


We didn’t bother to book a moment with Michelangelo’s David in the Accademia as we had both seen it before and were content to get a daily look at the copies around the city.


On the Piazzale Michelangelo

In the Piazza della Signoria

And after all was said and done, our top six, in no particular order were:


Uffizi Gallery Davanzati Palace

Museum of San Marco Galileo Museum

Basilica of Santa Maria Novella Bargello Museum


The impression you are left with at the end of the day is that creative centres like Florence happen for a reason. And quite simply, that reason is wealth. Despite being devastated by the Black Death in the mid-14th century, Florence rose to riches through a combination of textiles and banking. And the undisputed leader in that vein was the Medici family, which started in textiles and ended in banking. Evidence of the family in the city is rampant, with their coat of arms - an arrangement of balls or dots (anywhere from 6 - 11) - seen in almost every palace and church (I have to admit that when I saw them on the floor of the Duomo I first thought they represented slices of pepperoni pizza, but alas, that interpretation doesn’t appear to have caught on in the academic literature), and three of the largest palaces having belonged to the family - the Medici Riccardi, the Palazzo Vecchio and the Pitti Palace.  


Pizza, anyone?

So, what does one do with a palace, especially one that is the length of two football fields, as is the Palazzo Pitti? Fill it with art, of course, and in the case of Eleanor de Medici, your 11 children. In one room alone there were five Raphaels; nearby, a couple of Tintorettos and Titians, and these masterworks were scattered about amongst a horde of other paintings in sumptuous rooms where there was as much going on up on the ceilings as there was on the walls . But at times one couldn't help but feel there was just too much. How many Madonna and Bambinos do you need to buy a ticket to heaven? It was a bit of a relief to leave the art and gilt behind and take a walk through the Costume Museum that the palace now features in the south wing.


One of Raphael's four Madonna and Child paintings in the Palatine Gallery

of the Pitti Palace, the Madonna dell'Impannata

With 11 children, it helps to have a crib that will last

What's a palace without a statue of Venus

Nothing like the wedding dresses we've seen over the past year

In some of the palaces the art took your breath away, as in the Magi Chapel, a small chapel in the Palazzo Medici Riccardi which featured an imaginative take on the procession of the three magi over three frescoed walls. Each of the magi and many of the members of their retinue represented historic figures, some living in Florence at the time, and others past rulers. The opulence oozes out of the walls in glittering gold and rich shades of red and blue. But unlike the Palatine Gallery of the Pitti Palace, the art served a purpose, adorning a place of prayer and reflection.


A detail from the Three Magis (not to be confused with the 3 Amigos)
by Benozzo Gozzoli (student of Fra Angelico)


The Galleria degli Specchi in the Palazzo Medici Riccardi, where dignitaries were received

and guests could be persuaded of the power and wealth of the Medicis

(encouraged by the ceiling painting: The Apotheosis of the Medicis)


The Palazzo Vecchio was originally conceived at the end of the 13th century as a building to house the Florentine government. Taken over by Cosimo I of the Medici family, it was restructured and decorated in the 16th century to be a palace to house his family. And now that the building acts as a city hall, there is a mix of domestic and official functions evident. The most memorable room is the Salone dei Cinquecento, which was originally built to hold meetings of the town's Grand Council of 500. When Cosimo was done with it, it featured Giorgio Vasari’s massive (and nevertheless ho-hum) Battle of Marciano fresco, and an amazing gilded ceiling with scenes from Florentine history, with, you guessed it, Cosimo being glorified in the centerpiece.


Vasari's humongous frescoes in the Salone dei Cinquecento

The crowning of Cosimo

But in some ways, our favourite palace could have been the one that we never planned to see (and the Medicis never got there hands on): Palazzo Davanzati. On Thursday, we ventured out knowing three things for certain: 1) we had a reservation to climb the tower of Palazzo Vecchio at 11:30am, 2) we wanted to see the Museum of San Marco before that and 3) our 72 hour Firenze Cards ran out at exactly 12:13pm. So how long does it take to climb 233 steps, and where could we rush to after descending the tower before the clock struck 12(:13)? My calculations suggested that at a Catherine-paced walk (read: moderate jog) we could reach the Palazzo Strozzi before our cards turned into pumpkins. Well, unlike Cinderella, we did manage to keep all four shoes on our feet, but to no avail, as we rushed into the palace only to be told that they had just closed (for some event, apparently)  - come back tomorrow, he suggested - ha, if he only knew our distress! So, with only 007 minutes to spare, we made a mad dash to the closest palace covered by our card - the Palazzo Davanzati. Needless to say, we had no expectations; and often, that is the best plan of all. As it turned out, the palace charmed us in ways none of the others had. In the first place, it was small, almost intimate, being made up of four floors surrounding a small interior courtyard. And although it could not boast of artworks by Lippi or Fra Angelico, a good number of the rooms had delightfully painted walls - peacocks featured in one, parrots in another, and one told the 13th century chivalric story of the Chastelaine of Vergy around the four walls. And to top it all off, we shared the whole palace with a total of 8 other tourists.



Two of the rooms of the Palazzo Davanzati

The inner courtyard of the Palazzo Davanzati, looking up (notice how it narrows)

As I say, the art wasn't 'great', but some of it was great fun!

A view of the Duomo from halfway up the tower of Palazzo Vecchio

From the top of the tower

One might have thought that by mixing things up between palaces, churches and museums, you would have had a variety of experiences, but I couldn’t help but feel that there was a single, and perhaps narrow, theme running through them all, and that was 14th and 15th century art. To the trained eye, art that extends from Cimabue and Duccio to Leonardo da Vinci encompasses a wide variety of styles, a history that saw art evolve from symbolic Byzantine figures painted with little expression, depth, context, action or interaction to the dramatic figures that seem to live in a real world within the canvas or on the wall. To take your time (Catherine spent 4 hours in the Uffizi alone) and consider what distinguishes Fra Angelico from Botticelli, what makes Michelangelo great and Dosso Dossi not so great, and what purposes art can serve at different times is to be drawn into a whole world of aesthetic appreciation.


And what I discovered is that even though the subject matter was largely limited to the bible and the saints, the variety was immense and I came to recognize there were artists I appreciated more than others, and that not all of them had familiar names. Stand out experiences included the Botticelli room in the Uffizi (which was wall-to-wall tourist-sardines), the Fra Angelico frescoes in the Museum of San Marco, including his decoration of each of the monk’s cells and the second Annunciation we have seen this trip (the other Catherine described in our last blog entry), the Spanish chapel in Santa Maria Novella featuring a massive fresco by Andrea di Bonaiuto, the Michelangelo crucifix in the Basilica of Santo Spirito featuring a naked Christ, and the equally slender and nude David by Donatello found in the Bargello Museum. In the end, I came to believe that artists of the time succeeded in encouraging an appreciation for the central stories that give life to the Christian religion, a sense that the figures that populated the stories were full of awe, but at the same time shared our humanity.


Primavera, in the Uffizi. Either Botticelli had more beautiful models,
or a keener sense of how to capture a woman's beauty - I'm not sure which


Fra Angelico's Annunciation (San Marco)

A detail from Fra Angelico's Madonna and Child with Saints (San Marco)
and my favourite depiction of the Christ child

The amazing fresco in the Spanish Chapel at Santa Maria Novella

Michelangelo's Crucifix
(stock photo from the internet - we weren't allowed to take pictures)

Donatello's take on David

Another favourite from the Uffizi - Gentile da Fabriano's Adoration of the Magi (detail)

Was there anything other than art? Well, there were gardens, but after having experienced the gardens of France, the Florentine giardini were a bit of a let down. Especially after we had walked, at the end of a long day of walking, up a steep and endless road beside a high wall (cars and Vespas buzzing by) to i giardini Bardini, following the signs, I might add, only to discover we had been directed all the way around the gardens to the nethermost entrance. It would have taken a lot of trees and flowers to make that worthwhile, and really, there weren't. And it didn’t help that the entirety of the Boboli gardens visible from the Pitti Palace were covered in scaffolding and sheeting. Catherine did however enjoy the Fountain of the Little Snouts - or at least she enjoyed it until she discovered all those little birdbaths were used to catch birds.


In another season this Bardini walkway would have been festooned with Wisteria flowers

Snouts galore!

And in other non-art experiences, thanks to our son, Nicholas, who suggested we visit the Museo Galileo, we got a fascinating look at a wide variety of scientific instruments, some of which were used or developed by Galileo, as well as a mappa mundi, optical illusions, and great and intricate globes detailing the courses of the planets worked out according to Aristotelian calculations...with the earth at the centre. All that labour! All wrong! Also preserved for our enjoyment was Galileo’s finger, which was rudely positioned in a manner that he might have reserved for Pope Urban VIII and the ten cardinals of the Inquisition that forced him to recant heliocentrism. Later that week we saw his tomb in Santa Croce: belatedly recognized by the very church that scorned him.


Nicholas contemplates the world as it was once imagined

Of course, he could be pointing to the heavens

Is it art, or is it science?

An anamorphosis - add that one to your vocabulary!

Best of all were the views of Florence that could be had from so many vantage points, including Piazzale Michelangelo, a 25 minute hike from our apartment (which we loved!), and of course the Torre of the Palazzo Vecchio. Arguably, the views were yet another example of the city’s artistic heritage, particularly given Brunelleschi’s dome. And from the distance of the hills rising from the left bank of the Arno, the crowds miraculously disappear, which is how we will choose to remember it.
























Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sunday Edition: Notre Dame

A Three-Day Diet of Cheese, Chocolate, Chateau, Chapelle, and Charming Arts & Music

A Tuscan Wedding